How to Find Companies Similar to Your Best Customers
Find companies similar to your best customers: the traits worth matching, seven sources from review sites to SEC codes, and how to vet each lookalike.
TL;DR: Pick three to five customers you would gladly sign again, write down the traits they share, and search places that group companies by those traits: your customer's rivals, review-site categories, SEC industry codes, investor portfolios, vendors' customer pages, job posts that name the same tools, and lookalike databases such as Crunchbase's Similar Companies. Vet every match by hand against your must-haves. A lookalike shows who could buy, not when, so wait for a timing signal before you write.
Here is how to find companies similar to the customers who pay you best. The method is the same for an agency, a consultancy or a B2B startup; only the traits change.
Choose the customers worth copying
Copy outcomes, not logos. The famous name on your homepage may have taken nine months to close and a discount to keep. Pick three to five accounts that:
- signed without a long fight;
- paid on time, at your normal price;
- stayed past the first renewal or the first project;
- used what they bought;
- sent you a referral, or would.
If those five split into two groups, such as software companies and staffing firms, you have two profiles. Run two searches, never one blended search.
For each of them, write down what was happening when they bought: a new hire, a funding round, a migration, a new leader. That situation is the timing you will look for later.
The traits that make two companies alike
"Similar" should mean similar on the traits that predicted the sale. Write them down, then mark three or four as must-haves. The rest break ties.
| Trait | Example from a best customer | Where to check it on a lookalike |
|---|---|---|
| What they sell | Scheduling software for veterinary clinics | Homepage headline, product pages |
| Who they sell to | Clinic groups with five or more locations | Customers page, case studies |
| How they sell | Annual contracts sold by a sales team | Pricing page: a price list, or "talk to sales" |
| Size | 60 to 150 staff | Company page, careers page |
| Stage | Raised a Series A in the past 18 months | Press page, funding databases |
| Location | US headquarters, remote team | Contact page, job post locations |
| Tools the team runs | HubSpot and Snowflake | Tools named in its job posts |
| Situation when they bought | Had hired its first RevOps lead weeks before | Job posts, team page |
The two traits most lists skip are who they sell to and how they sell. Two companies in one industry can buy for opposite reasons: a payroll software company and a payroll services bureau share a keyword and little else.
Seven places to find companies similar to your customers
1. Your customer's own rivals
Your best customer knows who it competes with, so ask on your next call. Then search for "[customer] competitors", "[customer] alternatives" and "[customer] vs". Comparison pages name the companies that fight for the same deals. Google's help page on search operators lists site:, quotes, the minus sign, before:, after: and filetype:, and no operator for similar sites, so search with words.
2. Review-site categories
For a software customer, find its category on G2 or Capterra. The category page lists the products buyers weigh against it, and the companies behind them often sell to the same market. Skip the giants at the top of the list and look at the companies closest in size to your customer.
3. Industry codes
Companies that file with the SEC carry a Standard Industrial Classification code in their EDGAR filings, which indicates their type of business; 7372, for example, is prepackaged software (SEC SIC code list). EDGAR's company search lists every filer under one code, with its state. The list keeps long-gone filers, so check each company for recent filings.
4. Investor portfolios and accelerator batches
The fund that backed your customer often backs companies at the same stage, and its portfolio page lists them. Y Combinator's startup directory filters its companies by batch, industry, region, company size and whether they are hiring.
5. Vendors' customer pages
Companies that sell to the same buyers as you publish logo walls and case studies. A vertical software vendor's case studies are a list of companies in that vertical, picked by the vendor's own idea of fit. Trade association member directories and trade show exhibitor lists do the same job in older industries.
6. Job posts that name the same tools or roles
If your best customer ran HubSpot and was hiring a RevOps manager when it signed, search job posts for the same tool and the same role. Hiring signals explains what each role says about a team, and companies by the tools in their job posts shows the same search as a standing one.
7. Lookalike databases
Crunchbase company profiles include a Similar Companies section. A machine learning model builds it from industry tags, company descriptions, firmographics and financial data, and Crunchbase notes that full access to its predictions is for Business customers (Crunchbase). Treat every suggestion as a candidate to vet, not a verdict.
Ad platforms use the same word for something else. Meta describes a lookalike audience as a way for your ads to reach new people who share characteristics with your existing customers (Meta). It is a setting for ad delivery, not a list of companies you can research.
Vet each lookalike before it goes on the list
A model or a category page proposes; you decide. Run every candidate through five checks:
- Must-haves, pass or fail. One failed must-have takes the company off the list, however good the rest looks.
- False twins. An agency that "does SaaS marketing" is not a SaaS company. Read the homepage and the pricing page before you trust a category tag.
- The situation. Check whether the lookalike is where your customer was when it bought. A company that hired its RevOps lead last year is past that moment.
- A spot check. Vet the first 20 by hand. If fewer than half pass, your traits are too loose: tighten them before you pull more.
- Exclusions. Remove current customers, open deals and partners. Agencies should also check their conflict rules, since some clients expect you not to work for their direct rivals.
Add a reason to write before you reach out
A lookalike tells you a company could buy. It says nothing about this month. Before you write, look for one of these at the account:
- a job post for the team you support;
- a recent funding round;
- a tool you work with, named in its job posts;
- a post by someone there about the problem you solve.
Buying signals in B2B lists more, with where to see each one. Accounts with no signal go on a watch list that you recheck once a month.
Never open with the resemblance. "You remind us of one of our clients" reads as surveillance, and naming that client without permission breaks a confidence. Ask about the situation instead.
Find the people you sell to at each lookalike
Look for the title that bought at your best customer. If a head of operations signed there, find the head of operations here, and keep the signer for later. How to find decision makers in a company covers the sources and the checks. Then put each account, its signal and its people into your prospect list.
Finding lookalikes of your best customer with Pancake
Pancake is our product. Its lookalike search starts from a company you name: give it your best customer, and it finds companies that look like it, then the people you sell to at each one. Every lead is checked against the ideal customer profile in your GTM Brain and arrives with one line on why it fits; the people it sets aside show the reason.
A lookalike carries no timing, so run it next to a Play that does, such as companies hiring for the team you support (companies hiring) or companies that recently raised. A lookalike Play reads: "Our best customer is Kestrelway Payroll. Find US companies like it with 50 to 200 people, then their heads of sales." When a lookalike also shows a signal, the first message leads with it, never with the resemblance: "Saw the two SDR openings. Is outbound new for you this year, or growing?"
The limits: Pancake doesn't scan websites or follow the news, and it doesn't send email. Its messages go out as direct messages under your name, and a reply stops the sequence. Lookalike searches spend credits from a plan that runs from $99 a month per workspace with 60,000 credits (pricing), and the 7-day free trial comes with 30,000 credits once a card is on file. See lookalikes among the example Plays.
Frequently asked questions
- How do I find companies similar to another company?
- List the traits that made that company a good customer: what it sells, who it sells to, how it sells, its size, stage, location and tools. Then search places that group companies by those traits: its competitors and comparison pages, review-site categories, SEC industry codes, investor portfolios and job posts. Check each match by hand before it goes on your list.
- What are lookalike companies?
- Lookalike companies share the traits of your best customers: the same kind of product, the same buyers, a similar size and stage, often the same tools. Sales teams use them to build account lists in markets they already win in. A lookalike shows fit, not timing, so it still needs a reason to write, such as a job post or a new funding round.
- Is there a free way to find similar companies?
- Yes. Ask your best customers who they compete with, search their alternatives and comparison pages, browse the review-site category they sit in, read their investors' portfolio pages, and list SEC filers under the same industry code on EDGAR. Crunchbase profiles also show a Similar Companies section, though Crunchbase keeps full access to its predictions for paying Business customers.
- How do I find more customers like my best customer?
- Pick three to five best customers by outcome: they closed without a fight, paid well and stayed. Write down what they share and what was happening when they bought. Find companies with the same traits, vet each one by hand, then wait for the same situation to appear, such as the same hire or a new round, before you write to the person who owns the problem.
- What is the difference between lookalike audiences and lookalike companies?
- A lookalike audience is an ad-targeting feature. Meta describes it as a way for your ads to reach new people who share characteristics with your existing customers, so it delivers ads rather than handing you accounts. Lookalike companies are named businesses you research and contact yourself, chosen because they share your best customers' traits.